Bangladesh Prime Minster Hasina accuses brutalised demonstators of play acting and smearing their bodies with red dye
This is the prime minister of Bangladesh Sheikh Hasina Wajed lying in Parliament about the government brutality of the 5th and 6th May. First she gets the month of the incident wrong and has to be corrected.
Lest it get lost in social media ephemera here is the most vital snippet of the speech
"..and that day's event was fully televised, you have seen how they have rubbed red dye onto their bodies and when police came and called them they got up and ran away... we saw that dead bodies made a run for it! this kind of drama has been made there." [4m 30s to 4m 46s]
For the rest of it she repeats the stories that her government has been cocreating with the press like the Dhaka Tribune and the Daily Star.
A common political hue
In the boastees of Bangladeshi developmentia.
I am told
Is an acquired taste.
And, who knows, perhaps literally
It is worn for show,
A transnational con-trick
From the diasporas of dinia
And the djuice degeneration.
Its a Subaltern benefit cheat sheet of power.
So wave your kites you scoundrels
To catch wind
With disconcerting facility.
Feign feminine fragility.
Feed that nonsense engine
Know that you have become like Yahya's regime,
The one you flagellate about,
But just with better art,
Sorry, I meant PR.
And an epic bindi.
With a magnitude proportional
To inverted radicalism
On the Shapla Squared.
Its about a black brother who is initialy hired by American spy masters to fulfill some racial quota, but is then assigned to photocopying. In response to this, our comrade learrns all that he can and then leaves to set up an organisation to train the vanguard for the upcoming race war.
The significance of this report, speaking up and encouraging
This is an important document for growing our understandings and inquiries into the worst incident of government and police brutality in Bangladesh since the slaughter of Biharis in the Khulna Jute Mills in early 1972. People who know a lot are afraid to speak up and bear witness to what has happened. In the words of Glenn Greenwald on the whistle-blowing intelligence worker Edward Snowden and his leaking of the CIAs plans to snoop on everybody, lets hope his courage is contagious.
So what is in this report and who have they been talking to?
As well as an analytical account, the report includes real-life and informative contributions from many of the people (and non humans ) that have become part of the Motijheel assemblage. The people featured are diverse, and realistically contradictory voices are included for the reader to engage with and puzzle through.
Four relatives of four difference victims who did not survive , a manager of a hospital that tried to treat the injured, a nurse, the organising secretary of Hefazot, the commander of the fire services, the Dhaka City Corporation's Waste Disposal Unit, its Transport Unit, the Director of the illegally shut down Diganta TV, the Public Relations Officer of the Border Guards, the Director of Rapid Action Battalion-1, a Media guy from the Dhaka Metropolitan Police, the guard of an ATM booth nearby, a madrassa teacher injured during the massacre, an anonymous journalist , a young boy working on a ward, a morgue official....
We learn a lot that we did not know already, that we weren't allowed to know by a corrupt, inbred press and largely self-serving political parties. It challenges the government's own disinformation campaign on multiple counts and expresses dismay at the silence of the 'educated sector of society.
I know how cruel our deshis can be, whether they wear secular or non-secular underpants. You might not however. Here's a narration of a part of the experience of an 18 year old student who was sleeping by the Water lilly monument to the 1971 victims, when the firing started.
"...while running, he saw 10-12 men lying still on the ground. He was found by two policemen and hit with sticks. He was then shot by the police in his right thigh and immediately lost consciousness. After a while, a splash of water on his face by a person wearing jeans and a shirt made him gain consciousness. The man then said to him ‘you did not die yet’, and kept hitting him. Majedul Islam then grabbed his leg requesting him to stop; however he was hit even more after that. At one point the police asked him to stand up and run. He was physically unable to run and was hobbling away when the police hit him from behind and he then tried his best to run away and managed to enter a nearby street."The report is like an exhibition. Its strength is not in visual glam, but in the human accounts and the resourcefulness of the authors who have been speaking to participants in an atmosphere of extreme fear and silence. It closes off with a demand for a credible investigation led by a retired supreme court judge and 5 starting points.
Will this document render this injustice legible, or will it be disinterest or terrorism marketing as usual?
Its a shame that after three days there is little acknowledgement in the local press, other than one dismissive presence in the new Dhaka Tribune which employs the Double Standards of Evidence of expecting methods to be shared (and no doubt authenticated by its corporate masters). Dismissal is one of the characteristic bumprints of the Bangladeshi establishment's Liararchy*.
So many question remain despite and because of this document, which is a beginning to 'unfold the truth'.
*They are not the only ones with characteristic bumprints however, another political segments mimicry of mediocrity leaves a lot to be desired.
And armed to the teeth
militarily and educationally
Gatekeepers of the nation
To deny your mere existence
It is time for reflection and socio-spiritual transformation, especially with Ramadan, the month of Qur'an ahead of us. What is the meaning of this strife in Bangladesh what does it tell us about the national polital condition?
The Brethren of Black Lotus, a non-partisan coalition of activists, artists, scholars, professionals and businessmen note
...that it is not a line in the land which divides us, nor our devotions to God and Justice, it is not simply access to resources either. Our lives and hopes are blighted by the fundamentalisms of secular nationalism which draw lines through our souls, our minds and our bodies.We challenge the titans of ceremony, ignorance and buerotic misdirection.
Ultra nationalist symbols.... check
Liberation motanarratives.... check
Occupy branding without irony.... check
Political partisan capture, mediation if not blue-printing.... check
Secularist political polarity .... check
Strategic Civic Tree Conservationism.... check
Crazy seculib intellectuals in favour of.... check
Muslim Islamophobia well expressed .... check
Better Art than the adversary.... check
Bandwagoning from seculiberalefty internationale and neocon-gineers .... check
Limits of bismilla capitalism on show .... check
#Occupygezi is anti government, #Shahbag was pro-government.
Maturity of response and depth of punditry to contest, and caress, the enraged.... uncheck. Oh desh where is your Zaman, your people of Aykol's eloquence and intellect if not exact politics?
Depth of social alcoholeering..... uncheck. Can't believe all that fuss over the right-to-get-pissed near mosques and schools, Turkey. Its as if the Alcopaks took over the asylum.
Leadership quality .... AKP have good conciliatory people iA
Nature of International press on the ground..... uncheck. Istanbul is a lovely place, the edge of Europe and an economy of plenty. Dhaka is difficult to move around, a centre for Developmentia, in the hinterland of Asia and only interesting for poverty, disaster and climate pornography.
Craig Murray on Talking Turkey
Muslim Matters on Twitter Idiocy
Hugh Pope blog injects a little realism
Any police brutality is abominable, whether in London Istanbul and Dhaka. But what can we say about this selective human rights response?
As the bodies of those murdered in a far more bloody episode of government brutality in Bangladesh decay, ignored for a month, covered up, disinterested in and even insulted in death, we celebrate the #occupyhypocrisy of the hipster lefty for falling for the same love-the-mob set piece so uncritically, again.
1, 2, 3 Easy as ABC ?
In a recent ABC (Australia) radio programme some progress is made in explaining the tribunals, if just at least to register the, probably consensual absence of Bengali Muslims from telling the story and the Bangladeshi establishment positions of Meghna Guhatakurta, a Dhaka academic whose father was killed by pak forces in operation searchlight, who says that 'victims are satisfied with the tribunal process', and Australia based Bina D'Costa, who pronounces Pakistan is a very peculiar way, who says that the independent government drew on soviet sources for the 3 million (multidimensional bollocks).
Listen here, its rare to hear both sides in the same programme because the seculib block maintains a total non engagement with the substance of their increasingly coherent and articulate companion's discourse. Dr Guhatakurta complains that the victim's don't have the international resources and connections that those accused of war crimes have. I think this is odd, given that a third of the educated bangladeshis int he world talk about little else than 1971 and that their discourse dominates the establishment literature and media's bias against non secular people.
Toby Cadman, London-based barrister assisting the accused in the tribunals, and Sarmila Bose, Oxford-based researcher whose 'Dead Reckoning' book the Bangladeshi establishment has been discriminating against and avoiding the substance of for 2 years, also feature in the edited programme. I think radio/sound is a good medium of integrating contesting voices from around the globe. As a multipolar learning exchange with the truth as the objective is nigh on impossible without descending to a cat-fight or a massacre, the indignity of playing this out over the airwaves of whitey seems inevitable.
I remember when Brick Lane Circles hosted Sarmila Bose in London, (watch it on Vimeo here) the Awami League establishment tried to institute a boycott against the platform by scaring the curious away from it. One competing west Bengali researcher, Nayanika Mukherjee made an ass of herself at the event and is on record blowing her top of.
It is interesting that the official gatekeepers of the victims of 1971 should suggest 'you are marginalising our voice', with the symbolically unassailable identity of being orphaned by this carnage, part of the present knowledge producing establishment, urban, academic, female and not of the majority religion. On the contrary, I think the 1971 establishment narrative has the greatest global soft power projection and have spoken about the Double Standards of Evidence in relation to the Motijheel incident recently. Take the comparative coverage of yesterdays police brutality in Istanbul and last month's massacre of protesters in Motijheel.
In Turkey yesterday the AKP government's urban development thinking (bismillah capitalism) and use of police came in for attack as they cracked down violently on Occupygezi protesters, killing one. Hardcore ultra-nationalist CHP and global occupy infrastructure then became one and the global media jumped up and down, not out of interest for public spaces, but because of the opportunity to give a non-secular government a good kicking. The constructive alignment of interests show that its not killing that's a problem, but who you kill, and the reporting interests and relay infrastructure around them.
|The corporate media has its weakness written into its business model.|
The #Occupy phenomena has been thoroughly captured by neoliberalism and bled of meaning for partisan national politicking. Frame your spectacle with occupy branding and range it against any political islam for easy digestibility and travel along the global left. Here we have Turkey' very own Shahbag movment, but with open alcohol, kissing (last week) and irresponsible (ab)use of mosque facilities.
Both government brutalities in Dhaka and Istanbul had equipment in common, the Otokar Kobra, a Turkish manufactured riot car. In the still captured here, a Dhaka Metropolitan Policeman is caught mid-fire in vehicle serial number 26. This is sad because Turkish Muslim political and civil society has done much for justice in Bangladesh and for the Rohingya. Chillingly, the Dhaka Metropolitan Police have been busy hobnobbing with the US Embassy over "Special Event Management"
|A young Dhaka Metropolitan Police officer fires into an unarmed crowd of what looks like a Otokar Kobra vehicle in the early hours of 6th Feb.|
The reporting infrastructure around the Martyrs of Motihjeel has been poor and largely ignored. With the main human rights NGO, Sultana Kamal's 300 strong Ain-o-Salish Kendra taking the side of the government generally on annihilation of opposition, and specifically Motijheel and Tribunals issues, the role of alternatives, like the smaller Odhikar organisation have become more important. They were amongst the first to press release strongly on it after the killings and provide some good data in their monthly review document which can be read online, and ends in their own 13 points.
There are other resources, like the group blog Kaagoj, the indomitable Basherkella Facebook group phenomenon ( get an editor and watch your backs guys), the committed February 28 Info initiative (whose image library and analysis is worth soaking in) and the analytical Khichuri .
I'm not sure that Odhikar accessed them, and feel that there is a great deal of parallel work going on on discovering the truth behind the Motijheel incident, but for various, but ultimately inexcusable, reasons, the important questions, data and spadework is not being done.
In the meantime the Bangladesh government, led for now by the Awami League, has been able to clean the scene, deceive the public and turn this into a fundamentalist/militancy issue. The main opposition BNP is not interested in establishing the facts, Jamaat e Islami Bangladesh are still running for their lives and I really do not know how to describe the (non) function of Hefazot e Islam at present. As the primary oppressed party, condolences and counselling should be offered, not derision and parasitical questioning.
This leaves the knowledge gap quite huge, but it is out there, some of it is digital and accessible to us, some of it human and scared and politically muted, a lot of it physical, think of all the damage to the urban fabric of dhaka that tell stories, bullet holes, broken glass and general detritus. This has not been properly dealt with, people on the ground who have not taken the initiative.
So we must, warts and all.
Looking through the Diganta coverage of the day and the night is useful to get a feel for progression of violence during the day, but what we really need to piece together are the reflected experiences from the day,
- from Lalbagh Madrassa where Hefazot seniors were headquartered, and surrendered.
- through the events around the National Mosque in which police and Awami Aligned thugs attacked protesters from early afternoon,
- and Motijheel where the government violence centred,
- as well as Kachpur (12km away from Motijheel, where there are rumours of hindi speakers being involved) and Hathazari (near chittagong) madrasas where community's resisted government attacks after the .
I recently came to know of an undergraduate engineering student killed, or shaheed depending of your persuasion, in the government attack on Motijheel. His Facebook account tells us of a young man very much of the middle class, educated in Government Laboratory School and Dhaka City College before gaining entry to the county's most (only remaining?) prestigious institution. His avatar was a cartoon of two young muslim men hugging each other, he liked Lord of the Rings, used to tutor kids and volunteered as part of the youth wing of the Lion's club. He liked Arundhati Roy and The God of Small things. He last posted on 20th April and I wish I could to right by his parents. Many of the other victims of that day and night will not have had such digital presences as the much vaunted 'Digital Bangladesh' is an unequal techno joke. Today (Monday) the New Age of Dhaka even misspelled his names in a report that at least proved the Governments account of non lethal force, a death toll of 11 to be false.
Lord raise you Rehan Ahsan and protect your family from the terror of state abuse. Help truth and justice be made from these despicable events.
What should be done now?
The task for us at this point is not a matter of producing and consuming media but of demonstrating a new kind of, often quite remote, collaborative citizen science and humanity.
Corporate media has its biasing built into its very business model, and so its no surprise that Al Jazeera has steadily got worse in its Bangladesh coverage over the past months as it tries to break into the US market. What happened in Bangladesh on 5th / 6th May is bigger than any one party or social group, and therefore it is vital that a solid chunk of diverse people work on this issue in an effective manner which carries the scent of the way of things to come.